Charlotte LR Payne
Charlotte LR Payne
  • About
  • Research
    • Traditional entomophagy in Japan >
      • An overview
      • Wild foraging and food insecurity
      • Imported insects compensate for a decline in wild foraging
    • The ‘semi domestication’ of wasps for use as food in contemporary Japan >
      • What can we learn from insect 'semi-domestication'?
    • Public health and edible insects
    • Wild and semi-wild harvesting in Zimbabwe
    • Wild harvesting in DRC
    • Gender roles in insect foraging and management
    • Edible insects in San Antonio Etlatongo, Oaxaca, Mexico
  • Publications
  • Blog
  • 日本語

How sustainable can a Cambridge college be?

1/27/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture
Recycling bins and bicycles are all over the city - but how sustainable is Cambridge, really?
I'm leaving Cambridge and heading to Burkina Faso next week. I'm looking forward to it, but there are things I'll miss. I'll miss being on (and in) the river, I'll miss being in a place that's so vibrantly alive with intellectual discourse, I'll miss the people whose earnestly good intentions are part of an increasing awareness of our own privilege and responsibility..but I won't miss the entrenched culture of arrogance and disregard for the wider world and the impacts we have on it. 

But happily, many people here are working hard to challenge that aspect of Cambridge culture. So, in the spirit of leaving on a positive note, I'm going to write a bit about that.
Picture
Recycling bins at King's College, enclosed in willow fencing woven by a student
In the wake of an entire decade of some of the hottest years on record, amidst clear evidence that anthropogenic atmospheric change is contributing to ongoing species extinction and extreme weather events, and with a US president who not only denies climate change but also restricts freedom of speech in the hope of perpetrating this denial, taking action to combat climate change is more important than ever.

Fortunately, many individuals and institutions recognise this, and one of them is this institution. The University of Cambridge reckons it is responsible for 240,000kg of CO2e annually, which is the equivalent of taking just over 23 consecutive round-the-world flights. But this figure is only an estimate for emissions by the University - its departments etc - and doesn't account for its 31 colleges.

Each and every college has its own carbon footprint, created by its energy and water usage, its building repairs and construction, its food and drink consumption, the travel undertaken by its members, and by the places it chooses to invest its money.

Last term, I went to hear Andrew Balmford speak on how the staff, students and fellows of Clare College have worked together to reduce their carbon footprint. It was inspiring and thought-provoking.

Picture
Clare College, one of the leading colleges working towards a reduced environmental impact
Andrew emphasised that reducing carbon emissions is not only good for the planet, it's also an effective way of (1) reducing spending, and (2) building a sense of community through teamwork. Climate change unites us against a common enemy, and tackling it head on can really bring people together. 

He gave a few practical examples of how Clare College has done this, and these were overwhelmingly low-intervention and high-impact. For example, minor changes to heating schedules (heaters now come on only in the mornings and evenings) and bin placements (recycling bins are in more prominent, accessible locations) meant that a great deal of money was saved on gas bills and waste collection. 

PictureThe lower part of the above photo: Cambridge colleges are many things to many people, & signs like these shape the way we relate to them
Cambridge colleges are interesting institutions: For students and academic staff, they are a place of work and a place of residence. Many can walk from their room to the library to the dining hall to the bar - and that's a full day's work, right there - without stepping outside, let alone leaving the college grounds. For corporations, they are luxury conference venues that promise fine dining and an illusion of prestige. For tourists, they are beautiful and inaccessible anomalies.

The effort that it takes a Cambridge college to manage and support this cast of characters is immense. And this effort is reflected in their carbon footprint: Smart management decisions can be adopted and adapted to make a college more sustainable. ​In many cases, these are minor decisions - 'nudges' - with an amplified impact.

Picture
Statues deep in thought on the front lawn at King's College, & trees on the backs just visible through the archway
But, the next steps involve a little more intervention: Divesting from companies that contribute to environmental degradation, for example, would make an enormous difference, but it's a tough step for any college to take. On a more localised level, changing cafeteria menus to reduce the impact of college catering can also have a significant impact but may be unpopular among many college members. We now know that a vegetarian diet has a far lower environmental impact than a diet that relies on ruminant meat - but how willing are we as individuals to take this step?

The lessons that can be learnt from attempting to make a college more sustainable are relevant to us all - not only for the small elite who run Cambridge colleges, but for individuals and businesses alike looking to reduce their carbon footprint.

0 Comments

BUGS by Andreas Johnson: A film review

1/27/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture
​I would strongly urge everyone who is interested in edible insects, food systems and sustainability to watch BUGS.
​
I’m very biased: I consider the filmmaker and several of the film’s characters to be good friends. But one of the reasons behind our friendship comes from the great deal of insight I’ve gained from knowing and working with them.

Spoiler alert: Like all good stories, this film gives us a problem, an apparent solution, an arising conflict and finally a resolution. But unlike all good reviewers, I’m going to talk a bit about the latter elements of the story as well as the former. So if you’d rather watch it an be held in suspense, please stop reading at the point (just below the screenshots) where I say ‘I have only one criticism’…

BUGS tells the story of a gastronomic research project: the team at Nordic Food Lab (the non-profit research arm of Michelin-starred restaurant Noma in Copenhagen) secured funding from the Velux Foundation to travel the world for three years investigating the deliciousness of edible insects. Along the way, they share their optimism, curiosity and joy with many, yet ultimately end up tormented by the inadequacy of their original vision. 

In the film, Josh, Ben and Roberto take us on a journey spanning six continents and many fascinating humans and insects. I can’t comment reliably upon the main characters in Bugs, because obviously I think they’re wonderful. But I can say with confidence that they’re personable yet genuine. Having seen Andreas (the director/producer) in action, I know that he worked hard to ensure that the people caught in his lens were habituated to his unintrusive presence, allowing him to capture moments of excitement, conflict and disillusionment without gloss or pretence. 

This is not a film that tells the world to eat more insects. It’s a film that tells the world to think more deeply.

I love BUGS primarily because for me, it ticks all the boxes: Visually, it is mostly beautiful and perhaps occasionally disgusting. Tonally, it makes me giggle at times, and makes me sigh despondently at others. Intellectually, it has moments that expose characters’ utter obliviousness alongside their deeper thoughts, conflicts and insights.

So it hits all the extremes, and never strays toward mediocrity.


I have only one criticism.

While BUGS certainly goes a lot deeper than any other publicly-distributed edible insect feature I’ve seen or read, I do think that at some points, it could go a little further.

In one memorable scene, Ben poses a rhetorical question in a conversation with an African smallholder: ‘Like, who cares how much money you’ve got in the bank account if you’ve got really tasty food in the garden?’

Josh replies with, ‘It’s easy for us to say that, because we already have that … for a lot of people who don’t - the grass is greener.’
I think this is a very salient point, and one that I'd like to expand on.

...Have you ever lived as a smallholder farmer in a developing country with delicious food in the garden?

While many rural farmers with biodiverse smallholdings do indeed have access to delicious food, the majority of them—those I know at least—aren’t satisfied with that.

In a culturally diverse world, they’re not particularly proud of being the world’s rice basket, despite attempts to aggrandise this image of rural smallholders. In practice, many farmers have aspirations for their children and grandchildren that go beyond primary food production. They wish to see their descendants flourish in a world that offers a range of knowledge, choice and opportunity beyond their own experience.

However, this hardly means they all want to produce and eat industrial-scale freeze-dried mealworms to make their dreams possible! Fortunately, there is no ultimatum between multi-national monoculture and pastoral poverty. There are always more than two options.

I don't believe that we should be telling the other 50%, Marie-Antoinette-style, what will bring them happiness and prosperity. After all, it’s our accumulation of wealth and assets that makes their extreme poverty possible in the first place.

Instead, if we believe in the power of insects, or any food, to change the world, perhaps we should start foraging for them, farming them and eating them ourselves, too. Perhaps the real potential of the edible insects movement lies in a greater connection to the – cultural, political and ecological - environment around us. And perhaps watching BUGS is a good place to start - it's a beautiful reminder of this environment and its complexities, and a provocative conversation starter.

I've been told there are plans for a follow up series that will look at some of these issues in more depth. Which is great news, because BUGS also gives us a sense of some fascinating stories that lie behind the footage that made it to the final cut, and I'd love to find out more about them.

Meanwhile, if you're interested and want to know more, there are some great ideas and info about insect foraging at www.bugsfeed.com.
​
0 Comments

      NEW: Subscribe here for email updates!

    Subscribe

    Categories

    All
    Agriculture
    Burkina Faso
    Caterpillars
    DRC
    Events
    Fieldwork
    Grasshoppers
    Japan
    Media
    Mexico
    Nutrition
    Publication
    Recipes
    Silkworm
    Southern Africa
    Termites
    UK
    Video/slideshow
    Wasps/hornets

    Tweets about @libertyruth

    Blog archives

    March 2019
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    January 2013

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.